You asked

Where should I go with my girlfriend of 5 years who is interested in italy and switzerland

Marshall's Recommendation

Italy and Switzerland together is one of the great travel combinations, and you have a lot of options depending on what kind of trip you want. My honest take: don't try to cover too much ground. Pick a home base in each country and settle in rather than racing between cities.

For Italy, Tuscany is the obvious answer and it's obvious for good reason. Base yourself somewhere in Chianti and you have everything within reach: Florence, San Gimignano, Siena, and some of the best eating and drinking in the country. If you're going to make one meal a proper pilgrimage, get yourselves to Panzano in Chianti and eat at Antica Macelleria Cecchini. Dario Cecchini is a genuine legend, and the whole experience, equal parts theater and substance, is something you'll be telling people about years later. For a base, the Ludlow crowd aside, a well-chosen agriturismo in the hills will beat any city hotel for romance.

For Switzerland, skip Zurich and Geneva for this kind of trip and go directly to Ticino, the Italian-speaking southern part of the country that most tourists completely overlook. The light is different there, the pace is slower, and it has a character that's neither quite Italian nor quite Swiss, which makes it fascinating. Ascona in particular is genuinely special: a small lakeside village with real soul, excellent food, and some wonderful places to stay. The Art Hotel Riposo there is one I know personally and it's the kind of place that makes you extend your trip. Stunning rooftop views over Lago Maggiore, live jazz on weekends, and a team that actually cares. It punches well above its price point. From Ascona you can also dip easily into the Italian lakes, which makes the whole itinerary feel wonderfully connected.

★ Marshall's Favorites
Via XX Luglio, 11, 50022 Panzano In Chianti FI, Italy
Scalinata della Ruga 4, 6612 Ascona, Switzerland · Mountains · $$$
Hidden gem in southern Switzerland. Stunning property with one of the most incredible rooftops (the views!) around. Live jazz music on weekends. Thoughtful touches everywhere. Wonderful team... Must visit
9
Marshall's
Rating
Via Castiglioni, 1, 50025 Montespertoli FI, Italy · Quiet · $$-$$$
Picturesque grounds & views. Great home base for exploring northern Tuscany. Almost too refined to have a good time. Not kid friendly
7.5
Marshall's
Rating
Via Vincenzo Maggio, 5, 80061 Massa Lubrense NA, Italy · Quiet · $$-$$$
Technically in Massa Lubresne, a small village at the beginning of Amalfi. Easier to get in & out of vs. Positano and other towns. Amazing views. Get a room w/ private jacuzzi for perfect sunsets
8.5
Marshall's
Rating